Night Owl Cookies - Orlando, Florida

Laura R.

I stumbled on this place while returning a package at fedex. As I walked in I was greeted with a friend smile. The place smelled amazing. Samples of the cookies were neatly displayed on the countertop. I ordered 2 cookies to go; both were warm 🙂 This place is amazing and a hidden gem. They certainly out-beat their competitors down the street. If you're looking for a dessert to share, this is the place!

Michelle S.

Decided to try these cookies on a whim! The size and cost is comparable to other cookie shops of this nature. The presentation of the cookies was a bit messy and absolutely nothing like their website photos. The flavor of the cookies was essentially just tasting pure sugar. We purchased a chocolate chip, Brookie (which the brownie portion has chocolate chips so it takes away from the brownie texture), s’mores and the rainbow. Good but nothing I’d go out of my way for again!

Valerie F.

I recently visited the shop to try a cookie while I was in the area. Upon entering, the atmosphere felt a bit uncomfortable as I was greeted with silence and some stares, without any initial acknowledgment. However, after I began asking questions, the staff’s response became much friendlier. As for the cookie itself, I tried the red velvet, and it was exceptional—definitely worth the price.

Michael P.

First time will definitely be back the brookie is delicious oh yeah I like this place way more affordable than crumble cookie will definitely promote this place

Catherine D.

DELICIOUS!!!! Must try and they are open until 2 am. They have the cookies on display which is awesome. Loved the dunkaroo cookie.

rosie

Yummiest cookies ever! We got Smores, Cookies and Cream, Dirty Diana and Funfetti. These all exceeded my exceptions in taste and even size (just because they looked smaller on their website). I would even say I prefer these to Insomnia Cookies. Definitely recommend if you’re in the mood for a sweet treat, and I’m looking forward to trying the rest of the flavors!

Edit- It’s been a few months since I tried Night Owl and I had to update my review. I’ve pretty much tried all flavors and they are all phenomenal and they have many different options to cater to your cravings that day. My current favorites are the Brookie and Rainbow over Bedrock, but their cookie base itself is so delicious I could eat a plain cookie on its own. This location in particular is amazing. The employees are all very nice and in my experience, work quick to get your cookies made ASAP. The Winter Park location is closer to me but Ill always make the drive to this one by UCF for that reason, especially because they make your cookies look great and are not stingy on the toppings like the other location lol. Overall, BEST cookies in Orlando! It’s criminal how underrated this place is!

Koko

Went here after seeing an Instagram ad for the cookies and I was not disappointed! The cookies are large like Crumbl cookies, but not as sweet and are more moist. I found the price to be a bit steep, but they are big cookies so it is about worth it for the price. I would definitely go here again!

Jean B.

This cookie shop is an absolute gem! The moment you step inside, you’re greeted with warm, welcoming vibes and the irresistible aroma of freshly baked cookies. The decor is cozy and charming, making it the perfect spot to satisfy your sweet tooth.

What really sets this place apart is Austin. You can tell he’s passionate about what he does—he knows everything about the cookies, from the ingredients to the baking process. He even took the time to recommend a few flavors based on my preferences, and let me tell you, they were spot on!

The cookies themselves? Perfection. Crispy on the outside, soft and gooey on the inside, with flavors that taste like they’re straight out of a dream. My favorites were the cookies and cream and Nutella.

Five stars all the way! If you’re looking for delicious treats and stellar customer service, this is the place to be. Can’t wait to come back!